Teacher in Alaska was likely killed by wolves
by Dan Joling / The Associated Press
Mar 11, 2010 | 9747 views | 33 33 comments | 47 47 recommendations | email to a friend | print
ANCHORAGE, Alaska - A teacher jogging along a rural Alaska road was killed in an animal attack and authorities say wolves are the chief suspects.

The body of Candice Berner, 32, was found Monday off the road a mile outside the village of Chignik Bay on the Alaska Peninsula, which is about 474 miles southwest of Anchorage.

Authorities said the body had been dragged off the road to the village's lagoon and was surrounded by wolf tracks.

In an autopsy report Thursday, the Alaska State Medical Examiner listed "multiple injuries due to animal mauling" as the cause of death for Berner, a special education teacher originally from Slippery Rock, Pa., who began working in Alaska in August.

The autopsy could not say which animals, said Col. Audie Holloway, head of the Alaska State Troopers, but wolves are the chief suspect.

"There's no other carnivores in that area that are out and active," he said.

Wolves, bears, foxes and other wildlife have disturbed bodies in the Alaska wilderness, but Holloway said the autopsy ruled out other causes that may have killed Berner. Additional tests could tie the death to wolves, Holloway said.

"If we're able to actually prove which animal, it will be through some kind of DNA analysis or through some expert that can maybe testify or explain how they know that it's a wolf," he said.

Troopers have plenty of circumstantial evidence leading them to point the finger at wolves.

"There were wolf tracks all around the body, and drag marks associated with those wolf tracks," Holloway said.

Tracks indicated more than one wolf was involved.

"From the number of prints at the scene, we're thinking there probably were, possibly, two, three, maybe four," Holloway said.

Wolf attacks on humans are rare and there has not been a documented case of a wolf killing a human in Alaska. But concerns over the large predators persist.

In 2007, villagers in the western Eskimo village of Marshall posted sentries at night on the town periphery to keep wolves out after a pack of wolves attacked and killed six sled dogs. A wolf killed by villagers turned out to be rabid.

In Chignik Bay, a community of 105 residents, villagers were already were on alert because of wolves running boldly nearby, said Johnny Lind, president of the village council.

In comments Thursday before the autopsy results were announced, Lind said wolf involvement was apparent.

"It's obvious. Goodness. It's obvious," he said.

Since Tuesday, people were not traveling alone, school children were accompanied to school and armed patrols on snowmobiles were looking for wolves, he said.

"Everybody's kind of staying close to the village," he said.

Multiple calls left for the spokeswoman of the Alaska Department of Fish and Game, Jennifer Yuhas, were not returned Thursday.

Most adult male wolves in Alaska weigh 85 to 115 pounds but they occasionally reach 145 pounds, according to the Department of Fish and Game. Females average 5 to 10 pounds lighter than males and rarely weigh more than 110 pounds. Wolves reach adult size by about 1 year of age, and the largest wolves occur where prey is abundant year round.

Rick Luthi, the Lake and Peninsula School District's chief operating officer, said Berner during her short time in Alaska tried to take in as many experiences as she could. The district distributed a photo of her on a district outing catching crab.

"She wasn't going to miss anything about living in that area," he said.

Under 5 feet tall, Berner had boxed and lately had been training for long-distance running.

"She was a gymnast by early training and was in very good physical condition," Luthi said.
Comments
(33)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
wildsteelhead
|
March 14, 2010
Let’s get down to some hard facts. Here is an excerpt from this article in adn:

http://www.adn.com/2010/03/09/1175725/wolf-blamed-in-death-of-villager.html?utm_source=twitterfeed&utm_medium=twitter

“But violent encounters with people are more rare.

Last September, a rabid wolf attacked a hunter along the Kuskokwim River near Kalskag, biting the man in his leg before being shot to death. The hunter lived.

In April 2000, a radio-collared wolf repeatedly bit a 6-year-old boy playing in a grove of alders at a logging camp northwest of Yakutat. The boy was not seriously injured.

Then in July 2006, a wolf attacked a schoolteacher walking off the Dalton Highway, along the Arctic Circle. The woman suffered cuts and gashes to her legs but survived.

McNay, who now lives in Kansas, is the author of a 2002 study published by the Alaska Department of Fish and Game that examined 80 wolf-human encounters in North America, nearly half of which involved elements of aggression among healthy wolves.

The cases in which wolves are most aggressive are the cases involving wolves that have become habituated to people, he said.

"There's only been one other case of a fatal wolf attack by a healthy, wild wolf in North America, and that happened in 2005 in northern Saskatchewan," McNay said. "It is extremely rare. There have been other cases, of course, of wolves behaving aggressively toward people.

‘The frequency of these cases seems to have increased in the past decade or so.’”

jlar555
|
March 13, 2010
For the past three or four decades, starting with the birth of the modern environmental movement and its wilderness/wildlife subcultures in the 1960s, the big bad wolf has emerged from the shadows into a new paradigm which portrays this wild canine as a symbol of unspoiled nature worthy of protection rather than prosecution. In defense of the wolf's new image, amid efforts to reverse centuries of calumny, the wolf lovers' mantra has been that there has never been a recorded wolf attack on a human in North America, fatal or otherwise. While that wasn't strictly correct, it nevertheless became an accepted truism. Now, however, that defense is no longer available with this widely publicized fatal attack on Ms. Berner, originally from the town where I took one of my university degrees, restoring the fabled image of the big bad wolf, giving the "wolf haters" their day in the sun. And it comes conveniently at a time when the Alaska Dept. of Fish and Game is contemplating another wolf control program, a euphemism for tracking, hunting and killing them and their dens of pups from the air in order to enhance ungulate populations, an exercise which has already been predictably condemned by PETA and others.

Joe LaRocca
oldowl
|
March 13, 2010
I read on msnbc.com this morning that there were footsteps around the body where it had been dragged, as well as the wolf tracks. Never read that here or anywhere else. Is it a possibility that something else happened to her, rendering her temporarily helpless, attracting predators, and then they finished her off to be the "cause of death"? I wonder if the autopsy checked to see if there had been recent sexual activity.

It is sometimes good to read more than one version of a story.
Oldmusher
|
March 12, 2010
Over some 35 yrs of living and traveling in the bush I had several close encounters with wild wolves, including having a pack of three adults approach within three yards of me while sitting in a blind. I had wolves follow me while traveling by dog team. A single adult wolf once walked up to a few feet of my lead dog while the team was resting. All of these encounters ended peacefully, and I never sensed any threat from the wolves. Nonetheless, wolves are wild predators and should never be taken for granted. Attacks on humans are exceptionally rare, but they have happened. All things considered, a person in an area frequented by wolves is far more likely to be injured or killed by a moose or bear - or a careless hunter.
rightmaker
|
March 12, 2010
Yeah,always be think'in about the two legged and four legged animals out there.
oldowl
|
March 12, 2010
You are right - even your own pets can kill you. Wolf dog hybrids have the same predatory nature and they have killed children from their own family that have cried, fell down, or run from them. Only one more reason not to breed them as they are as unpredictable as wild animals.

I still wonder why the woman was not warned if people were seeing many wolves around. I still think there may be more to this than we know.
TheAlaskaCurmudgeon
|
March 12, 2010
Wolf attacks on humans are exceedingly rare, but not unheard of.

I'm curious as to whether the victim's body was tested for signs of rabies. There is a bit of that south of the mountains I believe. If there is a rabid pack roaming a populated area, steps need to be taken to remove it.

People have been killed by all manner of animals - even their own pets. Our interactions with animals will always have an element of risk. But the animal most likely to harm us remains the homo sapiens.
rightmaker
|
March 12, 2010
Poor girl, why did she not have a proper appreciation for the wilderness.You should always be prepared if your going into such an area by yourself.I would'nt have anything less than a 357.
larch
|
March 12, 2010
Of course wolves have fun when they kill things. Why would any animal not be expected to enjoy their life and the things that they do to survive? Evolution guarantees that good feelings accompany adaptive behavior. But the very rarity of this attack means that the wolves in this area need to be exterminated. They are replaceable. We don't have an "innocent until proven guilty" system for wildlife, and we never should. Humans may be animals, but we have developed self-awareness and moral codes that don't exist among other species. (OK, so I don't know much about whales). We can't start confusing human justice with wildlife management. Just kill the wolves in the area lest somebody else gets attacked. This incident should have nothing to do with the ongoing controversy about predator management in Alaska. Unfortunately, though, it already has.
Mustang65432
|
March 12, 2010
My condolences to the family...This is truly a tradgedy. I would suspect that the wolves were hungry and opportunity presented itself. Typically, wolves would be threatened by human presence and run they must have had a very hard winter and been extremely hungry.
someguyinfbx
|
March 12, 2010
satriani45 --

Not smokein(smoking) anything. Not from the city, have lived in the woods most of my life (I'm over 40 and enjoying electricity and utilities to my dwelling for the first time), only time I've felt threatened by wildlife was when some sloppy squatter started littering up the woods around me and his food trash was attracting bears. How much 'joy killing' have you witnessed personally? I don't want stories that someone has told you just what you have seen yourself. I've never seen a 'joy killing' I have woken to scratches and pee staining on all 4 corners of my tent, seen their eyes in the night watching me from the trees and running off when they noticed they were spotted, forget the fear mentality and don't assume you know me these are intelligent animals that happen to be carnivorous predators just like us humans, they sense fear and just like us to them fear = unpredictability and thus becomes a threat. If the wolves and wildlife make you afraid stay out of the woods. By all means carry a gun in the woods for protection, but not out of fear.

satriani45
|
March 12, 2010
SOMEGUYINFBX, what you smokein? ,in real life wolves joy kill, you said{ they gave chase because they were threatened} ha right , city boy,stay out the woods , you have no id what wildlife will do, BOODROW good post,fact, thank you,,
Boodrow
|
March 12, 2010
Rule number one: If you are in Alaska where wolves and bears may be encountered CARRY A GUN.

If you are armed, you, not the animal decides who lives or dies. A smart person never leaves the decision up to the animal.
someguyinfbx
|
March 12, 2010
Living in Alaska means making a conscious choice to living in and among nature, even if you live in the major cities of the state. I tend to believe that unfortunately this woman saw the wolf/wolves got freaked out and panicked and ran started swatting at the wolves and in turn they did what wolves do.... they gave chase because they were threatened. A truly sad situation but, when you live in the wilderness it's always a possible reality, wolves have very little interest in humans and express more a curiosity towards us bipeds than aggression.

If this is used to promote the eradication of wolves and predators then by true logic all cars and guns,and, processed foods must immediately be removed from society for these things kill more people per day than are injured per decade by animal predation. Also by logic if people kill people then no jail just kill the killer/killers right. We should have the population down to zero in under a decade.

My .02
LostAlaskan99712
|
March 12, 2010
If wolves killed people every opportunity they had this wouldn't be the first time wolves have been suspected of killing a human in Alaska, how long have Euro-Americans been populating Alaska?

Moose are known to be responsible for many deaths in Alaska and we don't we start eradicating moose so people don't hit them on the roads or get stomped in the middle of town, do we. Y'all remember that young boy who got attacked by a moose on his way to school? Why no outcry for the eradication of that particular dangerous species?

Only a hypocrite would suggest that we need to eradicate wolves because they're "dangerous" when every day most of us live side by side with the most dangerous species of all- HUMANS!
fairbanksforever
|
March 12, 2010
Tragic. Horrifying. My condolences.

Cougars killed runners in California. Bears have killed runners in Canada and mauled Alaskan runners. A runner in Eastern Canada was killed by a pack of coyotes. Animals (and human predators, for that matter) don't register our good intentions. They are too hungry, instinctive and opportunistic. We are not always at the top of the food chain. Something we all need to keep in mind.

Running is great. Running alone can be risky. Sad, but true.
Doug_in_Salcha
|
March 12, 2010
Ran across a comment posted on another website...

“The wolves were just doing what wolves do best. Killing and eating anything with flesh. Fools want to populate the lower forty eight states with wolves. Pioneers killed them off for good reason... by someboby named ‘Stan’ on Vindy.com

The reason that our ancestors tried so hard to eradicate wolves in the late 19th and early 20th centuries was precisely because wolves, when roaming in large packs, fear NOTHING! They will attack and kill human beings if they have the opportunity...
Wingmaster
|
March 12, 2010
Wolves are among the few animals that kill for fun, and play with there food.
oldowl
|
March 12, 2010
I meant to say predator animal in my previous post. Although wolves are also a prey animal. Yes the BOG will capitalize on this and all the people who want to exterminate all the predators. There are unanswered questions here. Could something else have happened to this woman like a fall or ? and then the ultimate cause of death be the animal bite? She had been in AK since August and should have known better. On the other hand, running with a Walkman glued to her ear in an area like this is not too smart. Why did the community not warn her if it was so dangerous? Why was she not eaten by those wolves if they were so hungry? The timing of this right after the BOG meeting is incredible. Like I said before running is the wrong thing to do. We will never know all the answers here but I think there may be more to this story.
Wingmaster
|
March 12, 2010
My prayers and condolences to her family and friends.

Maybe everyone that wants to pet a wolf and save a squirrel will learn that this could happen anywhere, anytime, in this state and a person just needs to be careful. I hope this gets fowarded to Feral in Conn. Eat your heart out.
Newsminer.com encourages a lively exchange of ideas regarding topics in the news. Users are solely responsible for the content. Comments are not pre-approved by News-Miner staff. Please keep it clean, respect others and use the 'report abuse' link when necessary. Read our full user's agreement.