Vanity Fair reporter admits error in Palin article
by Heather Hollingsworth / The Associated Press
Sep 03, 2010 | 2012 views | 14 14 comments | 3 3 recommendations | email to a friend | print
KANSAS CITY, Mo. - A writer for Vanity Fair has acknowledged a case of mistaken identity in an unflattering article about Sarah Palin in the magazine's October issue.

Reporter Michael Joseph Gross describes Palin's youngest son, Trig, being pushed in a stroller by his older sister, Piper, before a rally in May in the Kansas City suburb of Independence.

"When the girl, Piper Palin, turns around, she sees her parents thronged by admirers, and the crowd rolling toward her and the baby, her brother Trig, born with Down syndrome in 2008," according to the article. "Sarah Palin and her husband, Todd, bend down and give a moment to the children; a woman, perhaps a nanny, whisks the boy away; and Todd hands Sarah her speech and walks her to the stage."

Later, Gross describes Piper joining her mother on the stage to "allow Palin to make a public display of maternal affection."

The problem, which was first reported by the website Politico, was that the boy the reporter described was another child with Down syndrome.

The mother of that child, conservative activist Gina Loudon, told the St. Louis Post-Dispatch that she told Gross during the rally that the child in the stroller was her son, not Palin's. She said she tried to make it clear because the two children look a lot alike.

"I told him that. And he ignored it," Loudon said. "It's not even like he didn't fact check - he just ignored facts."

Gross said in a written statement sent to The Associated Press that he was mistaken.

"Trig was with his mother the next day in Wichita (Kan.), but the child in Independence was someone else, and I regret the error," he said.

Palin was quick to call the article "yellow journalism" in a tweet. The article describes everything from stingy tips given to hotel staff to heated fights between Palin and her husband.

Doug McMarlin, a spokesman for Palin's political action committee, said in a written statement Friday that the article was a "collection of lies."

"As the message continues to succeed, the messenger will continue to be attacked by yellow journalists seeking to increase sales," McMarlin said. "Our focus remains on the historic 2010 election and the brave Americans that have courageously entered the public arena to bring commonsense leadership back to our federal, state and local offices."

Sarah Palin: The Sound and the Fury: http://www.vanityfair.com/politics/features/2010/10/sarah-palin-201010

Comments
(14)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
LostAlaskan99712
|
September 07, 2010
"Their [Chinas] standard of living is improving by leaps and bounds."

Hmmm, just as ours gets worse by leaps and bounds...

Did you even bother to read my comment, Vickie?

I am forced to use a computer that is made in China, of course (who isn't?) I've never tried to "hide" that all too common fact so stop trying to spin everything just because you know I'm right and you ain't got nuthin else, Vickie.

"I'll bet your computer was made in China or at least 50% of all of its components. But then you're a socialist and so it's okay."

LOL, so it's not okay for you to be typing on a socialist made computer, because you're not a socialist? Why do you even bother, Vickie? Have you been spending time in Bernie Karls radioactive hot spring water again?
Invictus
|
September 05, 2010
As usual, you've got it backwards, Lost. Corporate executives are bringing capitalism to the PRC and the Chinese are loving it. Their standard of living is improving by leaps and bounds. I'll bet your computer was made in China or at least 50% of all of its components. But then you're a socialist and so it's okay.

AP: -- "So, are you guys saying that tens of millions of jobs HAVEN"T been outsourced?!"

No one said that. You said ALL the jobs have been outsourced. That is a patently absurd statement and obviously, false.... since I have a job and I assume you do, too. As it turns out, every person who works and the Daily News Miner also has a job and in fact, about 20,000 Fairbanksans have jobs and about 50,000,000 Americans have jobs. Can you post a link to the statistic that show "tens of millions of jobs have been outsourced"?
LostAlaskan99712
|
September 05, 2010
Lol, do you anti-socialists realize that (mostly Republican, as far as I know) corporate executives have strengthened the largest SOCIALIST economy in the world (China) by closing factories here and reopening them there?

I guess the mantras of anti-socialists only apply to petty political arguments, and not real life.

If you are against a socialist government, and buy things that are made in China- YOU are a hypocrite. Further evidence would be the use of the word "socialist" as though it has four letters, while typing on a computer that was most likely made in a socialist country, at least the computer will have parts made by socialists.

It's funny to still see people clinging to cold war stereotypes, you guys must have had it pretty good back in the 50's-60's, I would probably be bitter too if all the ideals and morals I was taught as a child all turned out to be wrong someday, although it's sad to see so many people in such desperate denial. Oh well...

"Trig was with his mother the next day in Wichita (Kan.), but the child in Independence was someone else"

Eh? Sooo, why was her baby in another state?

And um, why didn't Palin HERSELF explain to anyone that the child on the stage was NOT her own? I mean, if they look so much alike... (you'd think you might want to explain that, otherwise it'd be easy to assume that the child is hers as she has a child of the same age and appearance, who was in another state at the time).

I can't imagine leaving a less than two year old baby of mine, in a different state, without EITHER parent? Sounds like Saruh was trying to pass of this other womans baby as her own, at the rally, because she was possibly trying to (pathetically) avoid any accusations of being a neglectful parent by choosing an "event" over the care of her baby.

I think she used Loudens baby as a stand in for her own, and it backfired on her. Now she (and Louden) are trying to use the reporters MISTAKE as a distraction to the meat of WHY she had another womans baby at that rally, as though he were her own, to begin with.
Afghanistan
|
September 04, 2010
AP - I do agree with you on one thing - both parties are at fault. I am not beholden to either party, rather, I consider myself to be a conservative libertarian.

I pretty much have the point of view that if you are an adult and you aren't infringing on anyone elses right you sould be free to do whatever makes you happy.

That's Real Freedom
skeptical2
|
September 04, 2010
So, the error was saying that the Down's child that Piper took on stage to meet Sarah and Tood was not Trip but actually someone else's child who looked like Trip. The corrected version is worse for Sarah--she used another child as a prop at one of her speechs when Trip wasn't available. Was the child's identity announced to the audience? Pathetic attempt to discredit the Vanity Fair article.
AggressiveProgressive
|
September 04, 2010
After reading the title of this article again, I have to add that Palin IS an error. Sorry, but the woman doesn't have a freakin' clue what she's talking about most of the time. That's why she doesn't do interviews with anyone but her corporate shill buddies like Sean, and Glenn, and Bill O'Really. "What do you read?" GOTCHA! LOL!
AggressiveProgressive
|
September 04, 2010
So, are you guys saying that tens of millions of jobs HAVEN"T been outsourced?! What do we manufacture here that pays a decent wage, Invictus and Afghanistan? Oh yeah, pharmaceutical drugs, cigarettes, alcohol, petroleum products, and a few cars (with foreign parts). And GMO crops, can't forget those. Are you denying that tens of millions of jobs of all kinds have been outsourced because of the policies of BOTH PARTIES? And what does that have to do with being a socialist, Afghanistan? Do you doubt the study that stated CEOs with the fattest paychecks sent the most jobs overseas? You guys are worse off than I thought. You're stuck on the partisan merry-go-round. "It's all Obama's fault!" "You're a socialist!" You're right about one thing, Invictus, I do say the same thing over and over, hoping it will sink in - BOTH PARTIES ARE SCREWING AMERICAN CITIZENS OVER! And jobs HAVE been outsourced by the tens of millions! If they could figure out how to send the service jobs over there too, they'd do it in a heartbeat.

Ivictus, there were still jobs here when Nixon was president, so you're mistaken about that last exaggerated statement of yours. :-) And yeah, if they'd let American farmers grow industrial hemp, America would be a LOT better off in myriad ways. But the crooked corporate government keeps them from doing it, even though it isn't even psychoactive. I'm asking you seriously. Why do you think that is?
Invictus
|
September 03, 2010
AP -- you shouldn't have to make such ridiculous and stupid exaggerations to make a point: ...ALL the jobs? ...only weapons and burgers? ...slave labor?

Really dumb. You're like a Batty Cathy doll that keeps saying the same thing over and over and over again. I'm sure you've been doing this ever since Nixon was elected. Amazingly, you did not cry "Hemp!" in your last comment.

Afghanistan
|
September 03, 2010
Hey, aggressive socialist, please let me know what this administration has done to stimulate the economy (in a non-socialist way) and what have the outcomes and consequences been. I don’t want you to tell me about Bush this or Bush that – I didn’t agree with a lot of Bush’s decisions over his last two years in office.
AggressiveProgressive
|
September 03, 2010
I forgot to add that Palin represents those CEOs with her "free market" rhetoric. She probably doesn't even realize she represents them when she spouts the term at every turn. She's like one of those old "Chatty Cathy" dolls, (except the dolls are probably a LOT more intelligent).
Afghanistan
|
September 03, 2010
Why does this paper, the newsminer, have an entire section dedicated to the intentional destruction of Sara Palin? When is this paper going to get off of the Palin diatribe? I guess Joe Miller is next on the newsminer hit list.
AggressiveProgressive
|
September 03, 2010
triproad - We'll never get out of a recession because all the jobs have been moved overseas so the CEOs could make more money. The only things America makes anymore are weapons and burgers, so what are people supposed to do for work? This was on Democracy Now this morning. "And a new study from the Institute of Policy Studies shows that CEOs who fired the most workers during the recession took home the highest pay. According to that study, the CEOs of the fifty corporations responsible for the biggest layoffs were paid an average $12 million—42 percent more than the average pay for the Standard & Poor’s 500. The study covered the period from November 2008 to April of this year. For 72 percent of companies, mass layoffs were announced during periods of profit and high CEO salaries." GREED is killing America, and BOTH PARTIES ARE RESPONSIBLE! Get over the asinine partisan argument. Yeah, it's Obama's fault that tens of millions of jobs have migrated to slave labor in other lands so CEOs could make more money. I'm no fan of Obama's, but he's not responsible for the lack of jobs in America. CEO greed is. But you keep deluding yourself into believing it's all the Democrat's fault. Whatever floats your ignorant boat.
triproad
|
September 03, 2010
Obama Declares Victory Over the Bush Recession.

By Roadtrip / The Associated Press

The unemployment rate increased a tenth of a percent today. This as a positive sign and proof that Obama's stimulus plan is working. Sighting this news and the resent slowdown in manufacturing Obama made this statement. "Good, good, my plan is working perfectly. Soon, I will rule the wor...HEY, is this thing on? Oh, it is. Well, as you can all plainly see, the Bush recession is over, thanks to me." Now if you will excuse me, I have a vacation to get back to."

bumpo
|
September 03, 2010
EXTRA!!! EXTRA!!! Read all about it. Left wing Vanity Fair journalist caught lying in hatchet piece about Palin.

Our next report is an exclusive about the sun rising in the east. Followed by a special news feature, "Why Water is Wet".
Newsminer.com encourages a lively exchange of ideas regarding topics in the news. Users are solely responsible for the content. Comments are not pre-approved by News-Miner staff. Please keep it clean, respect others and use the 'report abuse' link when necessary. Read our full user's agreement.