Fairbanks cyclists recall accident during Chena Hot Springs ride
by Tim Mowry / tmowry@newsminer.com
Jul 02, 2010 | 6075 views | 66 66 comments | 15 15 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Maddie Button, left, and Claire Ferree stand with their bikes Friday, July 2, 2010, that they were riding when they were struck by a car. The two 16-year-olds were riding on Chena Hot Springs Road two weeks ago when they were hit by a car from behind near Mile 8. Sam Harrel/News-Miner
Maddie Button, left, and Claire Ferree stand with their bikes Friday, July 2, 2010, that they were riding when they were struck by a car. The two 16-year-olds were riding on Chena Hot Springs Road two weeks ago when they were hit by a car from behind near Mile 8. Sam Harrel/News-Miner
slideshow
FAIRBANKS – All Claire Ferree remembers is the screeching of the brakes.

But Maddie Button has a much more vivid memory of the bicycle crash she and Ferree were involved in two weeks ago on Chena Hot Springs Road.

“I have a clear picture in my head of my bike flying through the air in front of me and my legs flailed out in front of me,” Button said. “We didn’t even hear the car come up behind us until we heard the scream of the brakes.

“We heard that, and before we had time to react, we were flying through the air, basically,” she said.

Button and Ferree, both 16-year-old runners and cross-country skiers, were near the end of a 25-mile training ride on Chena Hot Springs Road about 5 p.m. June 18 when they were hit by a car from behind.

The girls, who are best friends and will both be juniors at Lathrop High School, were riding two abreast on the shoulder of the road when they were hit. Ferree was on the outside of the shoulder.

The driver of the car, Lee Schultz, told troopers he was reaching for a cigarette when he looked up and saw the cyclists.

“I went up on the hood and cracked my helmet on the windshield,” Button said. “(The car) stopped and the force of that kicked me off the car onto the pavement.”

That’s probably when Button fractured her tailbone.

Ferree ended up in the ditch along the road. She was more banged up than Button. The accident peeled a patch of skin 6 inches long and 3 inches wide off her right shoulder, and her whole right side was badly bruised and scraped, especially her hip and thigh. She has a hole in the skin of her left knee, but doctors couldn’t stitch it up “because there’s nothing there,” she said. Ferree still is limping two weeks after the accident.

Her right ear was swollen and scraped, and the strap on her helmet cut her hair. Doctors performed a CAT scan because of her head injuries but found no damage.

“The doctor said she avoided a serious head injury because of her helmet,” said her mother, Diane Ferree.

The back ends of both bikes are demolished. The carbon-fiber rim on Ferree’s bike — actually it’s her mom’s, and it’s 6 weeks old — is in several pieces, including a tiny one that is imbedded in her cycling shoe.

“Better her shoe than her leg,” Diane Ferree said.

The accident was a parent’s worst nightmare, especially for Jim and Jennifer Button. Their house sits on a hill on St. Elias Drive, just off Chena Hot Springs Road at 7 Mile, only about a mile away from the crash site at 8 Mile.

“We heard the sirens, but we didn’t think it was related to her,” Jim Button said.

Then the phone rang, and the answering machine picked up. Maddie was crying on the other end.

“All we heard was ‘Mom. Mom.’ And then it clicked off,” Button said.

The Buttons jumped in their car and drove down to the road, following the sound of the sirens.

They quickly came upon the accident scene. The first thing they saw was Maddie’s crushed neon green bike.

“That was pretty shocking to see that,” Jim Button said.

Then they saw Maddie sitting up and knew she was OK.

Claire Ferree used a cell phone to call Diane after the crash.

“She couldn’t even talk to me,” Diane Ferree said. “Finally a lady who had stopped to help got on the phone and told me there had been an accident but that she was going to be OK. We pretty much panicked.”

Schultz, the driver of the car, was cited for failure to exercise due care to avoid a collision. Contacted by phone Thursday, he declined to talk about the accident.

But both the Ferrees and Buttons applauded Schultz for taking responsibility for what happened.

“He stuck around. He apologized profusely. He was pretty shook up,” John Ferree said.

Schultz’s insurance will pay for new bikes for both girls, or in the case of Ferree, her mom.

Maddie Button said the girls were lucky to escape with the injuries they did.

“I definitely think our bikes saved our lives,” she said. “We would have been flattened if our bikes hadn’t been under us.”

Contact staff writer Tim Mowry at 459-7587.

Comments
(66)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
thegirls
|
September 29, 2010
his is "The Girls" speaking. For all of your information, on June 18th we were not exhibiting any horse play or dangerous behavior in the middle of the road. We were on our road bikes being good to our bodies and getting some exercise and as far as we know thats not against the law. Every time some one passed us too close and honked their horns we simply said "sorry for being healthy Americans." We don't go play hockey or own horses, this is how we enjoy our exercise. There is not indoor rink for us to go to, or trails just for us. We make do with what we have and don't complain.

We live 12 miles from the nearest bike path and it is a waste of gas to drive all the way into town to go onto a short bike path. We were abiding by all road laws, by riding no more then two abreast and as far to the right as permitted. We were never swerving into the middle of the lane or into on coming cars. We were wearing our helmets, which saved our lives and we were not just trying to risk our lives. We had not PLANNED on getting hit by a car that day. We didn't just say, oh, lets go try and die.

For all of you that think we are stupid and careless, we are straight A students and do many sports through school and the community. We are taught in school to stay health and get outside, and unlike many youth in this country, we do.

Thank you to all of the people who have been nice and considerate to our unfortunate incident. And to those of you that say why don't you just ride on the bike paths, there are no bike paths that exceed 7 miles in Fairbanks and I don't plan to drive to anchorage to ride my bike.

We have never been mean or obnoxious to drivers in their cars and still never plan to.

What makes any of you think that we are less important than you. WE live in America, a free country. Our freedom never hurt you so give us the same space we give you.
1AhHa
|
July 07, 2010
Giving some thought to why bicyclists don't ride on the bike paths..

In one word: Speed! and probably the buzz you from risking your life.

I have wore out about 5 cars over the years.

They lasted about 300,000 miles each.

Three absolute truths I have learned are:

Speed kills, don't take chances, and yield to trucks.

---

One of the guys who raced his motorcycle to Homer from Florida claimed he averaged 95 mph.

Hummm

--- fsjjc

AKgirl23
|
July 07, 2010
Anchskier - although you do make good points about the ATV drivers and cars not stopping (i was once hit by a car riding my bike on college rd), don't you think 1ahHa has a point? it seems more logical to me to ride a bike path and get hit by a slow moving vehicle then a car going 55mph. you do seem like an experienced and safe rider, but i think we can all agree that riding on a road such as CHSR can be very dangerous, as in the case of these two girls. i'm sure other roads that are less busy will work just as well for training purposes. as for "lack of compassion for those of us who actually get out of our cars once in a while,"...don't flatter yourself with how healthy you are. Snowpony123 said she has horses, while I actually have a D1 hockey scholarship. some of us just don't like to bike...
1AhHa
|
July 07, 2010
"« anchskier wrote on Wednesday, Jul 07 at 06:22 AM »

AKgirl23 - Actually, you are not correct. In most cases, for those people who are training on bicycles (not just recreational riding, but actually riding at a decent speed and going a good distance), it is typically MORE dangerous to ride on pathways and sidewalks. [more]"

---

I am curious, do you carry a donor organ card?

I bet the chances of you ending up in the morgue are considerably more if you are hit at 55 than when you hit a parked car in a dive way.

You are playing on the highway while death dealing vehicles zoom by with in inches.

Have you considered getting your buzz standing next to the targets on a rifle rage?

yssfx

anchskier
|
July 07, 2010
AKgirl23 - Actually, you are not correct. In most cases, for those people who are training on bicycles (not just recreational riding, but actually riding at a decent speed and going a good distance), it is typically MORE dangerous to ride on pathways and sidewalks. Drivers do not stop before crossing pathways. They pull out all the way to the road before stopping. ATV riders kick so much gravel and sand onto the pathways that it is dangerous to make turns or even to hit the brakes at times when riding a road bike at any speed. Bikes are a hazard to other pedestrians on pathways and sidewalks when they are going anything at or above about 10mph.

I ride the roads most of the time becuase at least on the roads, drivers coming from side streets or driveways have a much greater chance of seeing me before pulling out. I also have more places to go if/when they pull out right in front of me.

Pathways and sidewalks are great for recreational users, but are not designed for or intended for things such as training for races.

Some of the people on here scare me, not only because of their lack of compassion for those of us who actually get out of our cars once in a while, but also because of their complete lack of understanding of the rules of the road. Posters like Snowpony123 who openly admit that they are driving recklessly, only having the option of hitting the bikers or running into oncoming traffic. Uh, it is your responsibility to SAFELY pass a bicycle on the road. You are not required to pass them at the instant you get to them. You might have to slow down for a few seconds so that oncoming car or cars can get by before the other lane is clear enough to pass safely. Bikers do not have to get out of your way immediately. If/when you signal them (horn honk or other similar signal), they are only required to move over as much as practical, meaning they don't have to pull over and stop or get off the road, just move over as far as they safely can which isn't always as far over as you would like. I won't try to hold you up, but I am also not going to pull into the gravel on the shoulder if riding my road bike. If there doesn't appear to be a good place to allow for safe passing, I will try to find a safe spot where I can stop and let anybody that is behind me pass, but it probably won't be at the instant you get to me doing 55mph.
AKgirl23
|
July 06, 2010
Snowpony123- I think you have a great point. especially coming from someone who has also had bad experiences with cyclists and actually lives on CHSR.

TheAlaskaCurmudgeon- since when does not liking cyclists on the road make someone not enjoy freedom? I'm pretty sure we all enjoy our freedom..otherwise we wouldn't live here.

It's not that we don't care about our fellow human beings, some of us just don't think it's right to have cyclists on the road when there are plenty of other pathways made specifically for them. It's also safer.

I happen to know these two and they are great girls. I'm happy they are safe and sure they're parents are relieved also. But I can almost garuntee they will be training on the bike paths now because they know it's SAFER
1AhHa
|
July 05, 2010
« unsolicited_opinion wrote on Monday, Jul 05 at 02:09 PM »

I'm amazed at the keen sense of entitlement of vehicle drivers and their lack of compassion for fellow human beings displayed by some of the writers here.

--- reply

We own it!

--

I have the exactly THE amount of compassion as the bicyclists have for the motoring public.

NONE, and go play some place else.

My personal recommendation: Moheuland Drive and I-5 there are 5 lanes of traffic in each direction! Traffic flow is 45 to 70 mph

--- ybewh

unsolicited_opinion
|
July 05, 2010
I'm amazed at the keen sense of entitlement of vehicle drivers and their lack of compassion for fellow human beings displayed by some of the writers here.

1AhHa
|
July 05, 2010


« TheAlaskaCurmudgeon wrote on Monday, Jul 05 at 12:36 PM »

Bicycling is freedom. Those who hate cyclists hate freedom. Anyone who hates freedom hates America.

snowpony and 1AhHa: Why do you hate America?

--------

Do you grant the motoring public the freedom to run over them? effoi

1AhHa
|
July 05, 2010
Regulation.. issue..

Current regulations allow the foolish to endanger their lives and the lives of the motoring public ake ME.

The foolhardy are exploiting the lack of regulation ie "No Bicicys" signage on CHSR.

However, signage is protecting drivers elsewhere such as Air Port Why and Johansen Fwy.

--

Now, if those who are anti-regulation will change the law to release motorists from any and ALL liability for collisions with bicyclists playing on the highway.

The problems will quickly be solved and the spare body parts supply increased.

The simple approach is for DOT to put up "NO BICYCLING" signs just like they have on other parts of the highway system.

The more complex solution is to allow drivers to plow them out of the way. Riding or playing on the RR tracks is a good example of plowing.

The lack of "Signage" in this case is a POLITICAL decision by DOT. There have been more than enough complaints, accidents, and injures to document the need to for "NO Bicyclist" signs on CHSR.

--- jerko

TheAlaskaCurmudgeon
|
July 05, 2010
Bicycling is freedom. Those who hate cyclists hate freedom. Anyone who hates freedom hates America.

snowpony and 1AhHa: Why do you hate America?
snowpony123
|
July 05, 2010
"Obviously from a liberal democrat praying for more government regulation." watii

What a silly, ignorant remark! Actually I am extremely CONSERVATIVE! My political affiliation has absolutely nothing to do with wanting to be able to drive safely on CHSR...where I live thus having to travel the road every day! I don't see it as a 'training' ground! And wanting to know that IF I am involved in an accident as a result of these 'cyclists' that they have insurance? That's liberal? No that's called maturity and wanting to make sure I am safe. As I said before, I don't go drive my truck around the hockey rink or the baseball field or the basketball court...there are trails for the cyclists! If these people ride on the highways they deserve everything that might happen to them! GET OFF THE ROAD or you may just get a little F-350 up your A^&*S!



watii
|
July 05, 2010
« snowpony123 wrote on Monday, Jul 05 at 03:20 AM »

"And...when was the last time they needed to get a permit or license to drive the highway? Or how about insurance? If they, the cyclists cause an accident, do they have the proper insurance to pay for damages, injuries? I would suggest that if they want to ride on the public highways, they get a license and get insurance and be RESPONSIBLE!!"

Obviously from a liberal democrat praying for more government regulation.
1AhHa
|
July 05, 2010
Snowpony123 ---

Amen!

The highway must be marked NO "Bicycling" just like the Johansen and Airport Way.

That marking protects the motoring public from liability when fools play on the highway.

These fools are threat to the safety of every driver.

In this latest example the driver got a ticket!

What about a ticket for the girls who were blocking the flow of traffic!.

--

Read "Faith-in-him"s Comments!

Those comments are representative of the spandex bunch.

---

lckkb
snowpony123
|
July 05, 2010
And for those of you who say that motor vehicles and drivers need to 'share' the highway with these cyclists...when was the last time they needed to get a permit or license to drive the highway? Or how about insurance? If they, the cyclists cause an accident, do they have the proper insurance to pay for damages, injuries? I didn't think so! I don't drive my pickup truck on thier DEMANDED FOR and PAID FOR BY THE TAXPAYER bike trails, so I would suggest that if they want to ride on the public highways, they get a license and get insurance and be RESPONSIBLE!!
snowpony123
|
July 05, 2010
It's unfortunate that the reporter didn't investigate a bit more and talk to the local residents who travel the Chena Hot Springs Road every day because they LIVE on it!! These cyclists are inconsiderate when on this road and are going to cause a major accident one of these days! The same week, I was travelling in to town with my horse traielr and 2 kids in my truck! About 4 cyclists, all decked out in thier spandex and HEADPHONES refused to get off the road!! they were riding four abreast and were in the VEHICLE lane! When I saw oncoming traffic, I had two choices...either I could SLAM on the breaks and risk injuring all OR I could vear in to the oncoming traffice because the cyclists refused to GET OFF the road! The last time I checked, the road was for vehicles that had insurance! It may sound harsh, but I do not feel sorry for these two girls! There are other less danerous areas for them to "ride thier bikes" than a public highway with lots of traffic! There was another occasion where there were about 6 bikers who were just standing on the side of the road and in the road acting indignant when cars were trying to maneuver around them! These cyclists need to understand that the highway is NOT a training area and they need to GET OUT OF THE WAY OF TRAFFIC!!!! Other "athletes" aren't using CHSR for thier practice or training areas...no basketball, baseball, skating etc is being done in the middle of the road!!
3centsWorth
|
July 04, 2010
I have to wonder if "Faith-n-Him" is related to "TruthInNews".......lots to say about nothing and nobody is going to change their mind.......
1AhHa
|
July 04, 2010


Faith-in-him

"I choose the highway over the bike path because I have almost gotten hit several times crossing the many driveways along the way."

--reply comment...

I don't know if they still entertain HS math students with "Probability Theory" or not but your chances of making 1 last ride to the morgue are considerably higher than getting clipped at 10 mph at a driveway vs hit by a car doing 60.

Getting smacked at will cure your carpel tunnel.

I can see the head lines in the News Miner --

"Bicyclist's Carpel Tunnel Cured After Being Struck By Gravel Truck"

Let us pray!

---

I have not had this much fun since we argued religion from November to March! 2009 posts.

----

cspby

Newsminer.com encourages a lively exchange of ideas regarding topics in the news. Users are solely responsible for the content. Comments are not pre-approved by News-Miner staff. Please keep it clean, respect others and use the 'report abuse' link when necessary. Read our full user's agreement.